India

Intelligence for Better Decision Making

ANI's lawsuit against OpenAI over AI training
Nov. 21, 2024 | Indirect Indicator

Indian news agency ANI has initiated legal action against OpenAI, accusing the company of unauthorized use of its content to train the AI model ChatGPT.

The lawsuit, filed in a New Delhi court, alleges that OpenAI not only misused articles from ANI but also fabricated stories attributed to the agency. ANI seeks licensing agreements similar to those OpenAI has with other major publishers. This legal move is part of a broader trend, with various global news organizations, including U.S. giants like The New York Times, having lodged similar complaints against OpenAI.

OpenAI has responded to these claims by stating it has ceased using ANI's content and asserts compliance with legal standards. During the initial court hearing, the judge instructed OpenAI to address ANI's allegations. ANI presented evidence, including emails showing its website had been flagged for internal blocking since September, to prevent further use of its content. However, ANI argues that their content is still present in ChatGPT due to missing deletion protocols. OpenAI counters these accusations by claiming its operations rely on publicly available data under the fair use doctrine and highlights ongoing collaborations with news organizations worldwide. The next court hearing is scheduled for January 28.

The Delhi High Court’s involvement on November 19, 2024, marked the onset of this dispute, which is the first copyright claim against OpenAI by an Indian media entity. This claim parallels other cases in the U.S., where several newspapers have challenged OpenAI similarly. OpenAI has so far managed to secure licensing deals with other prominent outlets, such as the Financial Times and the Associated Press. Despite ANI's previous proposal for a licensing agreement being rejected by OpenAI, the tech firm points to exploratory discussions with additional news organizations, including potential partnerships in India.

As the court proceedings continue, OpenAI's legal team has asserted that ANI's website was blocked within their system. Nevertheless, ANI maintains that its content is still being used without permission, raising further concerns about false attribution by ChatGPT. Justice Amit Bansal has indicated plans to appoint an amicus curiae to assist in navigating the complex legal terrain presented by this case, with OpenAI already grappling with numerous lawsuits across the U.S., Canada, and Germany. The subsequent hearing has been set for January.
Delhi's Comprehensive Response to Escalating Air Pollution Crisis
Nov. 21, 2024 | Government Actions

Delhi is currently grappling with a severe air quality crisis, as the Air Quality Index (AQI) has soared beyond hazardous levels, exceeding 450.

In response to this alarming situation, the government is considering reinstating the odd-even vehicle rationing system and work-from-home policies to limit vehicular emissions. Environment Minister Gopal Rai and the Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) government are actively monitoring pollution levels and making informed decisions based on expert recommendations. Simultaneously, the Supreme Court has mandated that all National Capital Region (NCR) governments enforce Graded Response Action Plan Stage 4 (GRAP-4) measures until the AQI improves to 300. These measures include the establishment of anti-pollution teams, the implementation of the odd-even vehicle rule, and the exemption of electric and CNG vehicles, while also banning most commercial vehicles under these guidelines.

In Gurugram, air quality has deteriorated further to 'severe+' levels. This has led local authorities to impose a 50% work-from-home requirement for private institutions and multinational companies starting November 20, 2024, in compliance with directives from the Commission for Air Quality Management. Minister Gopal Rai has urged Union Environment Minister Bhupender Yadav to consider cloud seeding as an emergency intervention to enhance Delhi's AQI, although this method remains contentious. Experts underscore the necessity for comprehensive strategies to tackle primary pollution sources, such as stubble burning, transportation, and waste management.

Dr. Soumya Swaminathan, former WHO chief scientist, advocates for a comprehensive airshed approach, proposing the establishment of an environmental protection agency to enforce stricter regulations. She emphasizes the need for collaborative and global efforts to combat pollution, notably pointing out that Delhi fails to meet WHO PM2.5 air quality standards, which has severe health and economic consequences for India.

The health implications of this crisis are evident, with hospitals reporting a surge in respiratory ailments such as cough, asthma, and bronchitis, predominantly affecting the elderly and children. In response, the health ministry has issued directives to bolster healthcare services during peak pollution periods, particularly around Diwali and during stubble-burning seasons.

Delhi's struggle to meet air quality targets is compounded by inadequate road dust control, vehicular pollution, and waste management. Mechanized road sweeping and tree plantation efforts fall short, while outdated vehicle emissions and delays in waste processing exacerbate the crisis. Additionally, initiatives like electric buses and charging stations remain underdeveloped. The limitations of the AQI scale, capped at 500, complicate accurate assessments when pollution reaches critically high levels.

In a bid to address these challenges, the Delhi Police have enforced Stage IV of the GRAP, prohibiting older diesel-operated medium and heavy goods vehicles, while schools have shifted to online classes. Environment Minister Rai has held meetings to discuss and emphasize the strict enforcement of vehicle checks to curtail emissions. With decreasing visibility and shifting wind patterns, Delhi continues to tackle its environmental crisis with a sense of urgency and a commitment to swift mitigation strategies.

Monitored Intelligence for India - Nov. 21, 2024


News
Media
309

Government
Releases
3

City/State
Releases
0

Embassy
Releases
6
Foreign
Service
Advisories
0
Academic/
Think
Tank
7


Podcasts
0


Videos
0

Social
Media
0

Business
Releases
0

Erudite Risk takes an all risks approach to intelligence reporting. We categorize key intelligence into one of 40 different risk intelligence categories.

The goal is to provide intelligence that allows decision makers to avoid being blindsided by what they may have missed, while informing them to make better decisions as well.

Risk Categories Reported on Today

Risk Category
Items Reported On
Corporate Corruption or Fraud
1
Geopolitical Conflict and Disputes
8
IP Protection
3
Political Scandal or Corruption
14
Supply Chain Issues
1
Epidemics and Pandemics
1
Pollution
11
Crime
10
Climate Change
3
Communal and Religious Strife
4
Regulation
3
Accidents
2
Privacy
3
Protest, Demonstration, Dissent
1
Strikes and Work Stoppages
1
Shifting Geopolitical Alliances
1

Erudite Risk also includes operations categories so you can monitor the environment for better decision making. Everything is tied together--what happens in risk affects operations and what happens in the market impacts risk profiles.

We categorize key intelligence into one of 30 different operations intelligence categories.

Different roles and functions within the organization can monitor different key issue areas. HR may monitor employment, wages, regulations, labor and management relations, etc., while P&L leaders may monitor overall developing trends.

Operations Categories Reported on Today

Operations Category
Items Reported On
Political Policy Resistance
1
Trade Issues and Numbers
3
Mergers & Acquisitions
2
Tech Development/Adoption
2
Bankruptcy-Insolvency
1
Legal Exposure
1
Bizdev-Partnering
2
Financial System Problems
1
Economic Growth
2
Politics and Elections
7
Inflation
1
Operating Results
1
Employment
1
Wages and Compensation
1
Energy Prices
1

Ecommerce firms should respect law of land: Piyush Goyal

The Economic Times | English | News | Nov. 21, 2024 | Regulation

Commerce and Industry Minister Piyush Goyal emphasized the necessity for e-commerce firms to comply with India's foreign direct investment (FDI) regulations. He criticized these companies for engaging in predatory pricing and questioned Amazon's reported $1 billion investment in India, suggesting it primarily offsets market losses without benefiting the economy.

Goyal reaffirmed that the rules regarding FDI in e-commerce are explicit, insisting that firms must operate within these legal parameters. He pointed to ongoing scrutiny of e-commerce practices, including investigations by the Enforcement Directorate into vendors linked to Amazon and Flipkart for possible FDI violations.

Current regulations allow 100% FDI through an automatic route in a marketplace model, where platforms can facilitate third-party sellers but cannot hold inventory or set prices. In contrast, investment is banned in inventory-based models. The Confederation of All India Traders (CAIT) has raised alarms about major e-commerce firms undermining small retailers and violating FDI rules, while the Competition Commission of India (CCI) investigates possible anti-competitive behaviors in the industry.

Congressional panel urges toughing the US-China trade relationship

Livemint | English | News | Nov. 21, 2024 | Shifting Geopolitical Alliances

A congressional panel has recommended a tougher trade stance against China, suggesting the rollback of a nearly 25-year-old policy that has contributed to China's economic growth at the expense of U.S. interests. The U.S.-China Economic and Security Review Commission's annual report advocates for ending permanent normal trade relations with Beijing, aligning with Republican lawmakers as tensions rise under the anticipated Trump administration.

The proposed changes would reinstate annual reviews of China's trade practices, enhancing U.S. leverage to address perceived unfair behaviors. This move indicates a shift towards a more assertive trade policy focused on protecting American industries and workers from economic coercion. The commission, formed in 2000 to evaluate the national security implications of U.S.-China trade relations, presented these recommendations amidst ongoing debates over China's integration into the global economy.

The 2001 decision to support China's entry into the World Trade Organization was based on hopes that economic integration would lead to political liberalization, which has not occurred. Since Trump initiated a trade war in 2018 to tackle trade imbalances, tensions have increased. Experts warn that proposed high tariffs on Chinese products could harm the Chinese economy and raise consumer prices in the U.S.

As of 2023, the trade imbalance with China is $279 billion, down from $418 billion in 2018. In September, Republican senators introduced a bill to revoke China's current trade status, arguing that providing China with trade benefits similar to those for U.S. allies is unjust. Rubio emphasized that the growing trade deficit has resulted in significant job losses in the U.S. Concurrently, a bill was introduced in the House by Rep. John Moolenaar, highlighting a bipartisan effort to reevaluate the trade relationship with China.

China's foreign minister meets Indian counterpart, calls for resumption of direct flights

The Economic Times | English | News | Nov. 21, 2024 | Geopolitical Conflict and Disputes

China's Foreign Minister Wang Yi has urged the resumption of direct flights and improved bilateral relations with India during a meeting with Indian External Affairs Minister S. Jaishankar at the G20 Summit in Rio de Janeiro. This call indicates a potential thaw in ties strained since the 2020 border conflict, which resulted in casualties and military buildup. Wang emphasized the need for progress in direct flights, journalist exchanges, and visa facilitation.

These discussions follow a breakthrough in October when Chinese President Xi Jinping and Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi met for the first time in two years and agreed to de-escalate tensions. Wang highlighted that the common interests of China and India significantly outweigh their differences, advocating for collaboration through mutual development.

Restoring direct flights and easing visa processes are crucial steps toward normalizing relations between China and India, focusing on development rather than discord as both nations aim to strengthen their partnership.

Try the Daily Briefing for your country of choice for two weeks--free of charge and with no obligation.

Have a service or subscription question? We'd be happy to hear from you.

How can we help?
Full Name:
Email Address:
Type of Inquiry:
Country of Interest:

Contact us for a free trial of the Daily Briefing for your country of choice.


We currently cover:
South Korea
Japan
China
Taiwan
Vietnam
India

info@eruditerisk.com

The Daily Briefing is delivered Monday through Thursday via email.

Each day's reports include a combination of:

Takes
Takes are our deep dives into a topic of enduring interest or concern. Takes include copious references to all the media resources we gathered to build them.

Developments
Developments are key issues and incidents being heavily reported on in country. These are the centers of local thought gravity around which everything else revolves.

Risk Media
Summaries and analysis of the most important risk issues reported on in media, arranged by risk category. Learn about risk trends and issues while they are developing--before they blow up.

Ops Media
Summaries and analysis of the most important operational issues reported on in media, arranged by operations category. See what's changing in your market, and what's not.

Government Releases
Government press and data releases on key economic data, regulation, law, intiatives, incidents. Straight from the government's press to your eyes in less than a day.

Embassy and Business Association Releases
Statements and news releases from foreign embassies and business/industry associations, including chambers of commerce.

The Daily Briefing is comprehensive!

The Daily Briefing can run 50-100 pages each day!

Luckily, Erudite Risk tailors every report specifically to you.

Content Filtering
We try hard to ensure that every piece of information included in each day's reports will be of interest to our readers.

To fulfill our goal of comprehensively monitoring the intelligence landscape and also keeping reports readable, we build big reports--then deliver only the information that applies to you.

Each Daily Briefing is a bespoke report matched to your concerns. Tell us what you want in it, or we can match it to your professional needs. It's that easy.